well you got to look at stats some or you got nothing to compare.
I read in [/U]gun mags years ago the 357 had the highest percentage of stops
on real leve people. the above link isa test on goats. an there is one on pigs some were as well.
the fact is according tot he experts your more likely to die from a 357 vs a 45 acp round . so if you had to choose id take a hit from a 45 acp..
what type of gun is better can be depated all day . A auto is more likely to fail after its first shot IMO an revolver holdsd less rounds an is slower. how ever a double action revolver only need to have the trigger pulled for the first round were the 1911 will need to be cocked as its not DA,
In the middle of the night in my bed room if Intruder were to come in he will be met with a 4" 357 with hot loads. all I need to do is find it an squease. I used to have a model 39 S&W in 9mm in its place but after a bump in the night situation were I was naked half a sleep an droped the mag out trying recall how to use the dam thing I decided a wheel gun was a better in home set up. when I was married she was taught all you need to do is aim an squesee it was that simple . later she learned to cock it for a better aimed shot first.
IN a real world no leo situation I bet 99% of defensive shootings are less than two shots.
as far as the tokarev goes I have read a lot of times before the 357 mag came along it was the most powerful production hand gun round. at 1500 fps in a t33 its got a lot going for it . at 100 yards its still able to hit with very little compensation drop if any. I have no idea were it would place on the list above but it would be up there with hollow points IMO .
I have a 9mm largo ( 9x23) an its no slouch loaded right.
If I can ever find a non chromed lined barrel for a tokarev Im going to open it up to 9x23 Winchester an it will do every thing a 357 can in a auto . I have actually looked into a making a longer than stock barrel for it in 9x23 win or 38 super so it can also be used for hunting an have a compensator. were the 9x23 win rates is a good guestion but if a 1911 can be done in 7.62x25 it can be done in 9x23 win an im sure has been.
its my under standing a 9x23 is at 357 power or better . if it can be the same as 357 in power an load then you could have a your cake an eat it to.
more an more criminals have bullet proof vests an I also think in this day an age a rounds ability to defeat a vest needs to be considered as well as its ability to shoot through car doors an other things.
I see in the list that that some 9mm loads are in the 90+ % range . not to shabby .
all of them are going to work if you place the round well.
inside noise an hearing damage are also a consideration . I don't want to be in a bed room when a 44 mag goes off your ear drums can be ruptured .
there are a lot of variables imo . im sure in all but long range the 45acp is going to do what you need it to do . you would not want to be standing 150 yards away if I was shooting at you with my tokarev or my 357 black hawk Im amaised how on they are at those ranges .
whats behind your target is also a concern will your round go throught the house an kill you neighbor .
if a were a leo id want to be able to shoot through a car door well. maybe through two. if im a home owner then I want it to no kill my son in the next room . again lots of variables.
there is if you carry the weight an size concerns . what round.gun combo can you live with day in an day out ????? the first time you don't pack that 45 acp 1911 because its to heavy or big will be the time there is trouble .
imo the best round is the one you are the best shot with that meets minmum guidelines or better. you got to hit it to stop it.